Forum Discussion

Michael_Dieter's avatar
10 years ago

Juniper EX Virtual Chassis SNMP v3 monitoring after a change in RE mastership ????

Further clarification---and BTW Im not faulting LM for the seeming interoperability. I cant say where the break is occurring yet.rnIve documented this behavior with both EX 2200 and EX 3300 families and at JUNOS 11.4R5.x and 12.3R3 and higher.

2 Replies

Replies have been turned off for this discussion
  • Can anyone share how they have solved the problem of maintaining SNMP v3 auth/Priv connectivity between LM collectors and a virtual chassis after there is a change in the RE mastership?

    Juniper offers 3 methods to set the local engine id:

    1)enter no config, and automatically the default ip address of the RE at the time of configuration is used --> communication will fail as soon as this RE is no longer the master RE

    2)set a value for the local engine id: this produces some interoperability issue between LM and the virtual chassis --> no snmp-discoverable datasources ever get discovered even though the switch logs no indication of SNMP credential failure

    3)use the MAC of the management ethernet port: well, this one will change too as soon as there is a change in RE mastership.

    I have an open case with Juniper support but I am sort of getting the run-around from them and there brand -new documentation support site is the equivalent of a Byzantine Labyrinth.

    Any ideas, feedback or comments are appreciated.

    Thanks.

  • Resolution reached: finally walked away in frustration from attempting to use SNMPV3 and Juniper EX Virtual Chassis.

    After extensive work with Juniper support, I discovered that even Advanced JTAC does not know how to make this work. While it is possible that LM SNMP operation might contribute to an interoperability issue, I am not interested in a line-by-line validation of adherence to RFCs. Regardless, I have serious doubts about Juniper's ability to preserve SNMPV3 communication across Virtual-Chassis Routing Engine mastership changes.

    SNMPV3 works very well with stand-alone devices...but I do not recommend it for use in Virtual Chassis.